• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Sexton’s Pizza

At Sexton’s Pizza, we believe in crafting unforgettable flavors that bring friends and family together. Located in the heart of Columbus, this pizza haven specializes in creating mouthwatering pies that cater to every palate. From classic toppings to innovative combinations, each dish is made with fresh ingredients and a passion for perfection. Our commitment to quality extends to our seamless delivery and takeout options, making it easy to enjoy a slice of heaven at home. At Sexton’s, every bite tells a story, inviting you to savor the essence of good company and great food. Discover your new favorite pizza experience with us!

LOCATIONS

Welcome to the flavorful world of Sexton’s Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Columbus, Ohio. Located at 360 W 3rd Ave, this pizzeria is not just a place to grab a bite; it's an experience that celebrates the beloved dish that is pizza.

Sexton’s Pizza excels in delivering a menu that skillfully balances tradition and innovation. Whether you're dining in or opting for the convenience of delivery or takeout, Sexton’s ensures that every pie is crafted with care and passion. The focus here is on quality ingredients, which translates to freshness in every bite.

  • Delivery and Takeout: Perfect for those evenings when you crave comfort food at home or a lunch on-the-go.
  • Location: Conveniently situated in Columbus, making it accessible for both locals and visitors alike.

The atmosphere at Sexton’s Pizza is inviting, blending casual comfort with a touch of urban charm. It's a place that beckons you to unwind, whether you're gathering with friends or enjoying a quiet meal on your own. The scent of freshly baked crust fills the air, creating an ambiance that promises something special awaits.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. Each pie showcases a perfect harmony of flavors, from the perfectly charred crust to the rich, tangy tomato sauce, topped with a generous helping of gooey cheese and a variety of toppings that cater to every palate. The balance of textures — the crispness of the crust juxtaposed against the melting cheese — creates a symphony that will dance on your taste buds.

But don't just take my word for it. A visit to Sexton’s Pizza transforms a simple meal into a memorable occasion, whether you prefer classics like margherita or adventurous options that challenge the status quo. With each slice, you sense the dedication to quality and the love for pizza that permeates every facet of the restaurant.

In conclusion, Sexton’s Pizza is not just another pizzeria; it’s a testament to what pizza can truly be when passion meets skill and quality ingredients. If you're in Columbus and searching for your next pizza fix, look no further than Sexton’s. Your taste buds will thank you!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Sexton’s Pizza
Carter Denny
Carter Denny

If youre a pizza lover, this is a musttry! The pizza is absolutely incrediblehands down the best Ive had in a long time. The thin crust is perfectly crispy, and the dough has such a great flavor that it really stands out. It strikes the ...

Mac Zafarana
Mac Zafarana

Couldnt even wait to take a picture before digging into this beauty. Maybe the best pizza in the city, definitely the best near downtowncampus. The crust is so good, so crispy, nice and charred. The pep cups, forget about it. Im not usually a ranch on pizza guy but this ranch is so good. Get this pizza.

Grant Donnelly
Grant Donnelly

Checked out Sextons tonight for the first time. Ordered online which was easy. The menu is very paired down they offer a 16 ...

Michael Raymond
Michael Raymond

Took a while to have the pizza ready for pick up on a Friday but it was really worth the wait. Absolutely delicious.

Wes Lanning
Wes Lanning

Pretty good Neapolitan style pizza. High quality toppings and love the ezzo pepperoni. Would go back for more. ...

Ross D.
Ross D.

Stupid good pizza. Authentic brick oven taste. This pizza should belong in a fancy Italian restaurant but its right here in Victorian Village.

Liz Airhart
Liz Airhart

After 16 years living in the real East Village of NYC, Ive FINALLY found a New York pizza in Sextons. Hallelujah! All of these other places that say theyre New York Pizza theyre not. This is the real deal. I will only be getting ...

David Brauer
David Brauer

Delicious pizza. Had the MIKE! New York style. Id like to try the deep dish style next time. So many differentunique specialty pizzas! Give Sextons a try. No dinein option, at least at the W. 3rd Ave, Columbus, OH location.